At a Glance
- Courts are reading cookie banners and privacy policies together, and comparing both with what a website actually does.
- A federal magistrate judge concluded that CIPA § 631 does not apply to internet communications, but that § 632 does.
- A banner that only pointed to a privacy policy did not establish consent to third-party data sharing.
- A banner that offers an opt-out but does not honor it can supply the “confidential communication” element of a § 632 claim.
- A consent defense depends on whether the privacy policy describes the third-party disclosures that tracking technologies actually make.
- SB 690, signed September 30, 2026, ends private pen register claims over website tracking but leaves §§ 631 and 632 untouched.
4 — Website tracking decisions from August 2026 that bear on CIPA §§ 631 and 632
$5,000 — CIPA statutory damages per violation
~2/3 — Share of active privacy litigation the California Legislature attributes to pen register claims, the category SB 690 now limits to the Attorney General (Troutman Pepper Locke)
August brought four decisions on website tracking technology that, read together, set out what courts now expect: a banner and a policy that say what a site actually does, and a site that does what they say. (Troutman Pepper Locke)
Why CIPA Sections 631 and 632 Deserve Attention
California’s SB 690, signed on September 30, 2026, ends private lawsuits over pen register and trap-and-trace claims (§ 638.51) arising from website and app activity. Only the California Attorney General may now bring them.
The change takes effect January 1, 2027, and applies retroactively to certain pending claims (back to roughly January 1, 2025).
SB 690 does not make the underlying conduct lawful, and it does not change Section 631, which addresses interception of communications, or Section 632, which addresses confidential communications.
The Governor’s signing message acknowledged that other CIPA provisions remain open to litigation. Plaintiffs are expected to rely more heavily on both sections, so early rulings on how they apply to websites are informative.
Four Decisions, One Pattern
The August decisions address different questions, but they point in the same direction.
Statutory Reach
A federal magistrate judge concluded that § 631 does not cover internet communications, while § 632 does. This is one judge’s conclusion, not settled law across California courts, and § 632 remains a live theory for website operators.
Banners That Only Point
One court found that a cookie banner that merely directed visitors to a privacy policy did not establish consent to third-party data sharing. The banner itself needs to describe what is happening with visitor data.
Choices That Are Not Honored
In another case, a visitor opted out of tracking and was tracked anyway. The court treated the broken choice as supporting the “confidential communication” element of a § 632 claim.
Similar allegations underlie six class actions filed in California between December 2024 and February 2025, several of which have since produced mixed outcomes.
Policies That Do Not Match Practice
A further decision held that a consent defense turns on whether the privacy policy describes the third-party disclosures the tracking technologies actually make.
What Courts Now Expect
Taken together, the decisions describe three things that need to agree:
- What the banner says
- What the policy says
- What the site does
A gap between any two can undo an otherwise reasonable setup.
| What Courts Examined | Where It Fell Short | What It Points To |
|---|---|---|
| Banner text | Referred visitors to a policy without describing the data sharing | A banner that carries the key message itself |
| Opt-out controls | Offered a choice, then tracked the visitor anyway | Controls that work as described |
| Privacy policy | Did not describe the third-party disclosures the tags make | A policy that matches current vendors and data flows |
What Privacy and Legal Teams Can Do
The pattern favors consistency over volume of disclosure. It’s recommended for teams to take the following steps:
- Compare banner text with the third-party technologies that actually fire on each page
- Test that opt-out and rejection choices suppress tracking, both before consent is given and after it is withdrawn
- Reconcile the privacy policy with the current vendor and data-sharing inventory
- Repeat these checks on a schedule, since site changes can quietly reopen the gap
How Usercentrics Helps
Closing the gaps among banner, policy, and site behavior involves both content and technical controls. Usercentrics Web CMP helps operators present banner language that reflects the technologies and purposes involved — as they change over time — and applies visitors’ choices to the scripts running on a site.