Skip to content

Connected Devices Are Listening: Bystanders, Children, and the Consent Gap

Resources / Blog / Connected Devices Are Listening: Bystanders, Children, and the Consent Gap
  • Consent frameworks assume one identifiable person on the other side of a device, but assistants, wearables, connected toys, and meeting bots collect data from everyone within range.
  • An owner can agree to data collection for themselves, and a parent can agree for a young child. Neither can agree for visitors, caregivers, coworkers, or contacts whose data an assistant ingests, and in all-party consent states the person wearing a device may carry the legal exposure.
  • Some products keep text descriptions of what they see and hear instead of recordings, which raises the question of whether existing rules on recording still apply.
  • In the EU, the GDPR, European Data Protection Board (EDPB) guidance, and the AI Act each reach part of the problem, while the Toy Safety Regulation does not apply until August 1, 2030.
  • In the U.S., wiretap statutes, COPPA, FTC consumer protection authority, and new California laws apply unevenly: SB 1119 and SB 867 were signed in September 2026, and a bill requiring recording indicators on wearables was vetoed.
  • None of the frameworks reviewed here gives a bystander a built-in way to learn that a device captured them.

Always-on assistants, wearables, connected toys, and meeting bots collect data from people who never saw a consent prompt, including children, and the person wearing a device may carry the legal exposure. This guide, written for privacy, legal, and product teams, compares how EU and U.S. rules treat bystanders, summarizes the 2026 California laws, and lists questions to work through now.

An owner reads the terms, taps accept, and a device starts collecting. Everyone else in range never sees the prompt.

That arrangement is the quiet assumption behind most consent design: one person, one interface, one record of a choice. It holds up on a website, but breaks down in a living room, a waiting room, or a video call where a notetaking bot has joined without introduction.

Two recent pieces in The Verge show how far the gap is stretching. One reports on Meta’s Muse, an AI personal assistant that asks owners to share not only their own data but information about friends, family, and contacts.

The other, a column on what counts as a “recording,” argues that companies building always-listening hardware are pushing to redefine the term. Together, they describe a market where the person who consents and the person whose data is collected are increasingly different people. 

The hardware is arriving at the same pace. On October 15, 2026, Amazon announced two always-listening Bee devices, one of them on sale at launch. Meta says it has fixed an issue that owners reported caused its Ray-Ban glasses to record without the “Hey Meta” wake phrase.

The second Bee device attaches to a phone and had no ship date, so it is not a wearable that has launched. Meta gave the “resolved” statement on October 13 and did not explain the cause.

Consent is personal. An owner who accepts a device’s terms accepts for themselves and, for a child, as a parent or guardian. They cannot accept on behalf of an adult guest or customer, a visiting child from another household, or a babysitter.

The people most often left outside the consent record include:

  • Siblings and other children in the home who are not the registered user
  • Visiting children and their parents
  • Babysitters, cleaners, and service technicians
  • Coworkers and clients on a call where a meeting assistant is running
  • Friends, family, and contacts whose messages or details an owner shares with an AI assistant

Three Ways Devices Collect From People Who Never Agreed

The mechanisms differ, but the result is the same. Personal data collection about someone who was never asked.

Ambient Capture

Microphones and cameras in toys, speakers, wearables, and meeting assistants pick up whoever is nearby. Amazon’s new Bee wearables, for example, are always listening and signal this with an LED indicator. The device cannot tell the person it was bought for from everyone else in range.

Data the Owner Hands Over

The Verge reports that Meta’s Muse relies on public information and on what an owner chooses to share, and that this can include details about other people. 

A Meta spokesperson told The Verge that an agent needs context about the people an owner interacts with to be useful, for example to recognize that an invoice came from the plumber the owner hired, and pointed to Muse’s opt-in process and privacy settings. 

Critics, including Signal Foundation president Meredith Whittaker, argue that clickwrap terms, the “I agree” prompts that bind a person to a company’s terms, replaced meaningful consent long ago and that responsibility should move from the person who clicked to the companies that built the system. 

The Verge also reports owners describing incidents, such as the assistant accessing millions of text messages they believed were off limits.

Derived Descriptions

Some products no longer store audio or video. They store what an AI system has concluded from it, such as a text description of events at home or a summary of a conversation. The next section covers why that distinction matters.

When a Device Keeps a Summary Instead of a Recording

Some new devices store what an AI system has concluded from audio or video, not the audio or video itself. 

Apple’s reported home camera is one example. On the first episode of his Power On podcast, Bloomberg’s Mark Gurman said the camera would have “no video recording.” Instead, AI would analyze the camera’s surroundings and send owners text descriptions of activity in and around the home, reportedly using facial recognition. 

Gurman said camera-equipped AirPods that Apple is reportedly developing would work in a similar way. Apple has not announced either product.

The Verge column argues that for most of gadget history a microphone or camera was either recording or it was not, and that AI hardware is blurring that line.

The design sounds protective, and in some respects it may reduce risk. For the person being observed, however, it doesn’t change the essential fact that a system watched, interpreted, and wrote down what they did.

The law does not always turn on storage. California’s all-party consent statute, Penal Code Section 632, covers using an electronic device to eavesdrop upon or record a confidential communication without the consent of all parties. 

The GDPR defines personal data as any information relating to an identifiable person and treats collection and other operations as processing, whether or not a recording file exists. A text description of what an identifiable person said or did can fall within those definitions. 

Privacy laws across U.S. states generally define personal information with language similar to, “any information that is linked or reasonably linkable to an identified or identifiable individual” (that exact language is used by at least seven states.)

How courts and regulators will treat summary-only devices remains largely untested, so this section provides only editorial analysis and not legal advice.

What EU Law Says About Bystanders

EU law is further along than most in naming the bystander consent gap problem. It does not solve it.

The GDPR Household Exemption

The GDPR does not apply to purely personal or household activity by an individual. Art. 2(2)(c)) Recital 18 states that the exemption does not extend to the controllers and processors that provide the means for that activity. An owner’s use of a device at home may be exempt, but the company behind the device and its cloud service is not.

EDPB Guidance on Voice Assistants

The EDPB’s Guidelines 02/2021 distinguish registered users, non-registered users who knowingly use someone else’s assistant, and accidental users who trigger it without realizing. They indicate that consent can only be obtained from registered users, and that non-registered and accidental users must still be informed about the processing.

The AI Act

Article 50 transparency obligations for interactive AI systems and for emotion recognition and biometric categorization have applied since August 2, 2026. Providers of AI systems that interact directly with people must design them so those people are informed they are dealing with AI, and deployers of emotion recognition or biometric categorization systems must inform the people exposed to them. 

The AI Act’s definition of a deployer excludes use in the course of a personal, non-professional activity (Article 3(4)), so a parent using an AI toy at home is not a deployer.

Separately, the Digital Omnibus on AI Regulation (EU) 2026/1744, entered into force on July 27, 2026. It moved the high-risk obligations to December 2, 2027 for stand-alone systems and to August 2, 2028 for AI embedded in regulated products, a category that can include toys.

The Toy Safety Regulation

Regulation (EU) 2025/2509 entered into force on January 1, 2026 and applies from August 1, 2030. Its Recital 15 links toys with AI safety components that require third-party conformity assessment to the AI Act’s high-risk category. Legal commentary notes that it adds no AI-specific requirements of its own and routes the substance to the AI Act, the Cyber Resilience Act, and the GDPR.

None of these instruments gives a bystander an independent notice or consent mechanism built into the product. Article 50(3) comes closest, but it covers only emotion recognition and biometric categorization.

What U.S. Law Says About Bystanders

The U.S. has no single rule. Federal wiretap law generally requires consent from only one party to a communication. A number of states, including California, Illinois, Maryland, Massachusetts, and Pennsylvania, require consent from all parties to a confidential communication.

Litigation Over AI Recording

In re Otter.AI Privacy Litigation, pending in the Northern District of California, consolidates cases that began with Brewer v. Otter.ai. The plaintiffs allege that Otter’s meeting assistant recorded and transcribed conversations without their consent, and several say they were never Otter customers. 

On August 13, 2026, the court granted Otter’s motion to dismiss in part and denied it in part, allowing federal wiretap, California privacy, and Illinois biometric claims to proceed. That ruling is not a finding of liability, and Otter has denied that any interception took place.

Who Carries the Risk

In all-party consent states, liability can attach to the person who makes the recording, not only to the company that sold the device. A wearer who records a confidential conversation without everyone’s consent may be exposed under statutes such as California Penal Code Section 632, and an employer may face questions when staff bring always-listening devices into meetings. 

Which rule applies can depend on where the conversation takes place, and the device does not adjust to that.

Children’s Privacy

The Children’s Online Privacy Protection Act (COPPA) requires verifiable parental consent before an operator collects personal information from a child under 13. It applies to services directed at children and to operators that know a child is using the service. 

That structure ties the duty to the child who uses the product. A visiting child who never registered, or a sibling who is not the account holder, fits poorly, which mirrors the gap for adult bystanders.

Consumer Protection Law and the FTC

Consumer protection law reaches connected devices, but it does so through what a company says about them. It does not give the people near a device a right to notice or consent. Section 5 of the FTC Act prohibits unfair or deceptive acts or practices, and the Federal Trade Commission uses it as its main privacy enforcement tool. Many states have comparable statutes, some of which allow private claims or attorney general actions.

Recent FTC matters show where that authority is strongest.

Deception About Data Handling

In 2023, Amazon settled two FTC cases for more than USD 30 million combined. The FTC alleged that Alexa kept children’s voice recordings and transcripts longer than Amazon had told parents, and that Ring let employees and contractors view customers’ private videos. The Alexa case included COPPA claims alongside Section 5. Amazon denied violating the law. 

Deception About What a Device Hears

The FTC has also pursued MindSift and 1010 Digital Works, alleging that they falsely claimed their “Active Listening” service could target ads using conversations overheard by smart devices. 

Both lines of enforcement turn on a gap between what a company promised and what its product did. For bystanders, this leaves two problems:

  1. Standing: Consumer protection law generally protects customers and people who relied on a representation. A guest, a coworker, or a visiting child may have no relationship with the vendor and may never have seen its claims.
  2. Injury: The “unfairness” limb of Section 5 requires substantial injury, and the FTC’s policy statement says emotional impact and other subjective harm are not usually enough on their own. Having a conversation picked up by someone else’s assistant may not meet that threshold without more.

None of this makes consumer protection law irrelevant. It means the exposure falls on the accuracy of a company’s own statements. Teams may want to check whether product descriptions, privacy notices, and sales materials that say a device “does not record” or that data is “deleted on request” match what the system does, including what it keeps as summaries or transcripts.

California’s 2026 Laws

California acted on several related bills this year:

SB 1119 ("Adam's Law")

Signed September 10, 2026, requires risk assessments, independent audits starting in 2029 for covered operators, and a private right of action for companion chatbots used by children. Core obligations begin July 1, 2027, and default parental controls turn off persistent conversational memory.

SB 867

Signed September 30, 2026, bars making or selling toys for children under 16 that include an AI companion chatbot from January 1, 2027 until January 1, 2031.

SB 690

Signed September 30, 2026, ends private pen-register and trap-and-trace claims tied to websites and apps from January 1, 2027, and applies to certain pending cases. Other California Invasion of Privacy Act claims, including wiretapping and eavesdropping, remain available to private plaintiffs.

SB 1130

Vetoed on September 30, 2026, would have required wearable recording devices sold in California from January 1, 2028 to carry a light, sound, or other signal prominent enough that a reasonable person nearby would notice the recording. 

Governor Newsom said the bill defined several terms too broadly or imprecisely, and that its definition of a wearable recording device could include certain smartwatches or other worn devices widely used in public spaces. He also noted that existing law already restricts recording where people have a reasonable expectation of privacy.

SB 1130 matters most for this topic. It was the California bill aimed most directly at telling bystanders that a device was capturing them. SB 1119 and SB 867 protect children who use chatbots and toys. Neither addresses the sibling, the guest, or the babysitter. For now, an indicator such as the LED on Amazon’s Bee devices is a design choice, not a California requirement.

Why the Gap Is Global

The pattern repeats outside the EU and the U.S. The UK Information Commissioner’s Office (ICO) Children’s Code includes a standard on connected toys and devices. It expects providers to be clear about who processes the data a toy transmits and keeps them responsible when a third party supplies the connected element. 

In Germany, the Bundesnetzagentur banned the “My Friend Cayla” doll in 2017 as a concealed surveillance device, saying that toys able to record and transmit without detection compromise privacy.

In the frameworks reviewed for this article, duties attach to a relationship with an identifiable owner or child. That structure is shared across jurisdictions, which is why the gap travels with the product.

Questions for Privacy and Product Teams

These questions do not yet have settled legal answers. Teams building or deploying always-on features can work through them now:

What notice does a person receive who has no account, no app, and no interface to the device?

Does the product retain, summarize, or infer from what bystanders say or do, and for how long?

If an assistant ingests an owner’s contacts or messages, can the third parties in that data ever see, correct, or delete it?

How does the product treat children who are not the registered user, including visiting children?

Would a physical signal, such as a light or tone, give bystanders notice that a screen cannot?

If a product is described as not recording, which statutory definitions does that claim actually address?

Do vendor contracts state who is responsible for informing people who are not customers?

If employees or customers bring always-listening wearables into meetings, which policies and notices apply?

Usercentrics Consent Management Platform (CMP) documents the choices of people who interact with a digital interface, such as a website or app visitor. It does not tell a babysitter that a toy is listening, and no configuration will change that.

Where consent infrastructure helps is upstream. It gives an organization a record of what it told people, what they chose, and which systems received that signal. Teams deploying AI features can apply the same discipline to map which data flows involve people who never saw a banner, so those flows receive different treatment that includes notice at the point of capture, data minimization, and shorter retention.

Usercentrics does not provide legal advice, and this article is for informational purposes only. Consulting qualified legal counsel regarding your specific regulatory requirements and business operations.

Map consent across your digital touchpoints

Usercentrics helps teams document consent choices and apply them across websites, apps, and TV platforms. Scales with your business as you grow. Try it free for 14 days.

Stay in the loop

Join our growing community of data privacy enthusiasts now. Subscribe to the Usercentrics newsletter and get the latest updates right in your inbox.