• EN
    • DE
  • Login
Consent Management Platform
Consent Management Platform (CMP) Usercentrics
  • ProductsHolistic Consent Management Software
    • Website Consent Management
    • Mobile Consent Management
    • AMP Consent Management (BETA)
    • Smart Data Protector
    • Automatic Privacy Policy
  • Solutions
    • GDPR
    • CCPA
    • CMP for Publishers
  • Pricing
  • Resources
    • Developer Documentation
    • Videos
    • FAQ
    • Knowledge Hub
    • Whitepaper
    • Webinars
    • RFI Template
    • What’s new?
  • Partner
    • Find a partner
    • Become a partner
    • Tech Partner
    • Expert Partner
    • Reselling Partner
    • Referral Partner
  • Company
    • About us
    • Career
    • Press
    • Events
    • Contact
  • GET STARTED NOW
  • Menu
GDPR & Cookies
June 9, 2020 | 2 min read

Federal Court of Justice rules: Cookies may only be placed with users’ active consent

Resources
Knowledge Hub
Federal Court of Justice rules: Cookies may only be placed with users’ active consent

Table of contents

Show more Show less

Anyone wishing to place cookies on internet sites for advertising purposes may only do so with the user’s active consent. Preset ticks for cookie consent are not sufficient for this purpose. This has been confirmed by the Federal Court of Justice (FCJ) in its ruling from 28th May 2020 in the case brought by the Federation of German Consumer Organisations (German: Verbraucherzentrale Bundesverband) against the company Planet49.

FCJ’s ruling ends years of legal uncertainty

The decision from the FCJ brings much longed-for clarity in the matter of “cookies for creating user profiles for advertising or market research”. In doing so, the FCJ follows the judgement of the European Court of Justice (ECJ). Following a preliminary ruling issued by the ECJ in October 2019 (after presentation by the FCJ regarding the format of consent), it is now abundantly clear that only active consent given by the user represents a valid legal basis for the processing of personal data.

No cookies without explicit consent

The FCJ confirms:

Pre-ticked boxes are not sufficient for obtaining valid consent.

Anyone wishing to place cookies on internet sites for advertising purposes must obtain the user’s active consent at all times. However, another latest development is that the FCJ does not currently see any need to amend the German Telemedia Law (TMG). Section 15 Par. 3 TMG is, according to the FCJ, sufficiently interpretable for compliance with legal guidelines, even if by a very narrow margin. For website operators the result is the requirement to obtain valid and therefore active consent. The unexercised right to object as stipulated in Section 15 Par. 3 TMG equates, from the FCJ’s perspective, to no valid consent having been given. This means that whereas the TMG could previously be interpreted as requiring the user to simply have the option to object, this is now no longer the case. The user must provide his or her active consent, as invalid consent is tantamount to an objection.

The case of Planet49 – what happened up until now

The case of Planet49 has taken up the time of various courts since 2013. Background: In an online raffle from the company Planet49, pre-ticked boxes consenting to the use of cookies had been placed on the registration page. Users who did not wish to consent had to actively remove the ticks. The Federation of German Consumer Organisations regarded this as illegal and filed a lawsuit. The Higher State Court in Frankfurt am Main saw no legal infringement in its ruling from 2015. The FCJ then requested the ECJ to interpret the EU data protection requirements.

In short, companies wishing to use cookies on their websites for advertising purposes may only do so
with informed, explicit and, above all, prior consent. Pre-ticked declarations of consent do not suffice
for this purpose, according to the FCJ.

A video of today’s ruling can be found here.

 

Authors: Jana Krahforst, Carolin Weißofner, Theodora Zamanakou, Legal Team Usercentrics

DISCLAIMER

The decision to implement a data protection-compliant CMP is ultimately at the discretion of the data protection officer and/or the legal department. These statements do not constitute legal advice. They merely serve to support and inform you about the current legal situation with respect to the implementation of a CMP solution. Please consult a qualified lawyer should you have any legal questions.

Related Articles

5 Tips for Handling Cookies Correctly in Live Chat Supportlive-chat_userlike
November 23, 2020
6 min read
GDPR & CookiesUsercentrics Best-Practices

5 Tips for Handling Cookies Correctly in Live Chat Support

Cookies aren’t just for tracking user behavior and displaying ads. They’re part of nearly every online tool, such as...

Read more
Brexit and the ICO Guidelines on Cookie Consent: How to be compliant after the transition periodBrexit - Article
August 13, 2020
5 min read
GDPR & Cookies

Brexit and the ICO Guidelines on Cookie Consent: How to be compliant after the transition period

The end of the Brexit transition period is quickly approaching – and publishers are wondering if their data strategy...

Read more
GDPR Cookies Checklist: Your Toolkit for ComplianceGDPR Checklist | Usercentrics
July 2, 2020
3 min read
ePrivacy & Privacy PolicyGDPR & Cookies

GDPR Cookies Checklist: Your Toolkit for Compliance

Uncertain about how to become compliant with GDPR and the ePrivacy Directive? We’re here to help. Future-proof your marketing strategy...

Read more

Next Steps

Scan your website

Scan your website

Check your privacy compliance
Request a demo

Request a demo

Schedule for free
Get started

Get started

See our pricing

Legal Update

Always up-to-date: With our legal update, we keep you up to date with the latest trends around data protection.

Products

  • Website Consent Management
  • CMP for Publishers
  • Mobile App Consent
  • Automatic Privacy Policy
  • Smart Data Protector
  • AMP Consent Management (closed beta)

Resources

  • Whitepaper
  • Case Study
  • On Demand Webinars
  • Live Webinars
  • Knowledge Hub
  • RFI Template
  • Videos
  • FAQ
  • Developer Documentation

About Us

  • Who we are
  • Career
  • Press
  • Events
  • Contact

Our Mission

Helping companies to achieve compliance in harmony with their marketing strategy.

Legal

  • Legal Notice
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms and Conditions

Address

Usercentrics GmbH
Sendlinger Straße 7
80331 Munich
Germany

© Copyright 2021 Usercentrics

This website and all services provided by Usercentrics are not intended for users and companies outside of the European Union, U.K. or Switzerland.

FAQ for the webinar IAB TCF 2.0 & Performance Marketing Usercentrics | FAQ TCF2 Webinar Consent Management Platform – buy or build yourself? - Usercentrics Consent Management Platform – buy or build yourself?
Scroll to top